---
title: "Copilot and Gemini barely scratch the surface of AI in business. — Marsanne Studio"
description: "What Microsoft 365 Copilot and Gemini do in a company equipped with their suite: a comparison rated from 1 to 5 stars use by use, published feedback from early deployments and what the vendors do not document."
url: "https://marsanne.studio/en/insights/copilot-gemini-workplace/"
lang: "en"
---

Comparison

# Copilot and Gemini barely scratch the surface of AI in business.

A company that claims to have "adopted AI" simply by buying Copilot or Gemini licences for its employees is like a manufacturer in the age of electricity.

Such a manufacturer would declare "that's it, we've switched to electricity" because he has replaced the entrance bell with a doorbell. In his factory, he still has no lighting, no machines able to run 24 hours a day without pollution, and no information system.

These companies have barely touched the subject. Their teams do not really see the benefit. They are often frustrated, even disappointed, with what AI brings them.

Vincent Piche, for Marsanne Studio · 10 November 2026

![A modern video doorbell, with a blue accent, is mounted on the wall next to a heavy old wooden door, in a soot-blackened brick factory wall, with a tall smoking chimney and steam escaping from a pipe.](https://marsanne.studio/_astro/copilot-gemini-entreprise.sU0JLHJc_2s1DE0.webp)

## Scope

As of November 2026, Microsoft and Google each sell an assistant built into their office suite, an agent able to chain long tasks together and a tool for building in-house agents. This article describes what each offering does in a company equipped with the corresponding suite, what licence it requires, and what remains poorly documented.

The sources are vendor pages (release notes, product blogs) and two third-party pricing guides, consulted on 9 November 2026. An announced feature is not always available everywhere: the labels “preview”, “Frontier programme” or “gradual rollout” are included where the vendor gives them.

## Rated comparison

The two tools receive similar scores: meeting minutes and drafting are their strong points; spreadsheets, presentations and the reliability of answers are their weak points. Each rating combines the documentation and published feedback (government trials, specialist press, forums); it remains a judgement.

| Use | Copilot | Comment | Gemini | Comment |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Meeting minutes | ★★★★☆ | + Most frequently cited use in the UK trials and on forums; useful for catching up on a missed meeting.− Accuracy not guaranteed; personalised summary suspended in April 2026. | ★★★★☆ | + Most appreciated use; notes in French and Spanish since March 2025.− Notes judged very generic; no multilingual meetings. |
| Document drafting | ★★★★☆ | + Largest reported gain in the UK government trial (24 min per task) and top use at HMRC (53%).− Loses context, fragile numbering and formatting, generic tone. | ★★★☆☆ | + Draft built from Drive, Gmail and Chat.− Few independent reports; Help me create still in beta; the Gemini app cannot edit a Doc. |
| Email | ★★★☆☆ | + Drafting and tone adjustment appreciated.− Very small measured gain in a public trial; inbox search inconsistent. | ★★★☆☆ | + Summaries and proofreading useful, especially for non-native speakers.− Enabled by default, can only be disabled as a whole; instructions hidden in an email executed by the summary. |
| Spreadsheets | ★★☆☆☆ | + Help with writing formulas; agent mode praised by some users.− Slower and less accurate than without Copilot in a public trial; invented rows. | ★★☆☆☆ | + Formula help judged effective; fixing of faulty formulas.− Invented data; incorrect table built from Gmail and Drive. |
| Presentations | ★★☆☆☆ | + Gain of 7 to 19 min per presentation according to UK trials.− Lower quality; output judged the weakest by service providers. | ★★☆☆☆ | + Image generation judged useful.− Little feedback; integration judged very limited; full decks too recent to assess. |
| Search across internal data | ★★★☆☆ | + Synthesis across emails, files and meetings praised by users at large accounts.− Surfaces any over-shared file; bug affecting confidential emails in January 2026. | ★★☆☆☆ | + Enterprise search drove adoption at KPMG (Gemini Enterprise).− Drive files not found (rare reports); same risk of over-sharing. |
| Long-running task agent | ★★★☆☆ | + Available since June 2026; delivers a complete output and can control the browser.− Feedback still scarce; credit cost hard to predict. | not rated | + Announced for tasks lasting several days, with sub-agents.− Availability not specified, no usage feedback. |
| In-house agents and connectors | ★★★☆☆ | + Agents built without code; MCP connectors deployable across the whole organisation.− Reliability “at 90%” according to one designer; confusing credit-based billing. | ★★★☆☆ | + Successful deployments at KPMG and Virgin Voyages (more than 50 agents).− Fewer than ten native connectors; assumes data that is already clean; start described as chaotic. |
| Reliability of answers | ★★☆☆☆ | + Better results with reasoning models.− 22% of testers noted invented answers; slowness and variability. | ★★☆☆☆ | + Fast answers.− Errors stated with confidence and no sign of doubt; most frequently cited theme in the feedback. |
| Governance | ★★★☆☆ | + Comprehensive Purview controls: labels, DLP, audit, eDiscovery.− Prior audit of SharePoint permissions judged essential. | ★★★☆☆ | + Drive permissions respected, protected files excluded, access logged.− Same permissions audit needed; usage reports only since February 2026. |
| Cost relative to usage | ★★☆☆☆ | + Copilot Chat included; 61% of HMRC users reportedly would be disappointed to lose their licence.− Full licence sold separately; few pilots move to wide deployment. | ★★★☆☆ | + Included in the subscription; cheaper for those who paid for the former add-on.− Price increase imposed in 2025; quotas, then a paid option. |

★: avoid as it stands. ★★★: useful if every result is reviewed. ★★★★★: reliable without review; no use reaches this level.

## Microsoft 365 Copilot

Copilot works on the Microsoft 365 data to which the user already has access, acts in Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook and Teams, and has had, since June 2026, an agent that carries out a task from start to finish (Cowork), billed on usage.

### Two access levels

-   **Copilot Chat**: included in eligible Microsoft 365 business subscriptions. Copilot Notebooks have been open to it since June 2026.
-   **Microsoft 365 Copilot** (paid licence): grounding in company data and advanced features in the applications. Several 2026 additions are explicitly reserved for it: scheduling in classic Outlook, Copilot in Forms, the Copilot search pane.
-   The release notes do not publish a table comparing the two levels feature by feature.

### Data reached

-   **Work IQ** is the grounding layer: email, SharePoint and OneDrive files, Teams meetings and conversations, Viva Engage. In 2026, Power BI reports and semantic models (Frontier programme) and Dataverse (general availability announced for September 2026) are added.
-   Work IQ is also exposed through a REST API for agents or workflows developed separately, billed per request since October 2026.
-   Answers respect existing access rights. Purview DLP can exclude external emails from Copilot’s sources (general availability July 2026).

### In the applications

-   **Word**: agentic drafting and editing, choice of model (OpenAI or Anthropic), images generated in the flow, edits driven by comments in the document.
-   **Excel**: creation and editing of workbooks in natural language, Python in “Edit with Copilot”, reusable “skills”, rule sheets per workbook, links to modified cells (November 2026).
-   **PowerPoint**: generation from SharePoint libraries or OneDrive folders, brand kit, reuse of the theme of an existing deck (October 2026).
-   **Outlook**: drafting and rewording, sorting (delete, move, categorise), scheduling that books a room, writes the agenda and sends the invitation (classic Outlook for Windows, phased rollout).
-   **Teams**: summaries of meetings and conversations; “AI Workflows” in the Workflows app (November 2026, disabled by default).

### Agents provided by Microsoft

-   **Copilot Cowork** (global general availability, June 2026): the user describes a task, Cowork breaks it down and delivers an output. It can control the local Edge browser for web steps, with credentials remaining on the device. Usage-based billing in Copilot Credits.
-   **Researcher**: in-depth research across internal data and the web, with choice of model and mode. Canva (October) and HubSpot (November 2026) connectors.
-   **Analyst**: data analysis through reasoning and code execution; absent from the release notes consulted.
-   Other agents: Planner (tasks and plans), SharePoint list creation, Learning agent.

### Building your own agents

-   **Copilot Studio** and the agent builder integrated into Copilot make it possible to create declarative agents (instructions, sources, actions) published in Microsoft 365 Copilot.
-   Administrators can create custom MCP connectors in the admin centre and deploy them to the whole organisation (October 2026).
-   Custom “skills” in Cowork, Excel and PowerPoint.

### Third-party systems

-   **Copilot Connectors**: indexing of external sources (e.g. ServiceNow, with its roles) or real-time querying without storage (“Federated Copilot Connectors”, via MCP).
-   **Cowork plugins** listed in June 2026: Harvey, LSEG, Miro, monday.com, Moody’s, Morningstar, S&P Global Energy, Enosix, TeamsMaestro; Databricks via manual loading; Microsoft Fabric and Dynamics 365.

### Models

GPT 5.5 Thinking by default in Cowork, Anthropic models (Opus, Sonnet 5) offered in Word and for Cowork’s visual work, ChatGPT Images 2.0 for images. The choice of model depends on the tool and sometimes on the Frontier programme.

### Costs

-   Microsoft 365 Copilot Business: $21 per user per month ($18 as a promotion until 31 December 2026), up to 300 users.
-   Bundles since 1 July 2026: Business Standard with Copilot $23.50, Business Premium with Copilot $32.
-   Cowork, the Work IQ APIs and some of the agents consume Copilot Credits: prepaid credits or pay-as-you-go, with budgets, alerts and per-group caps in the admin centre.
-   From 1 December 2026, usage-based billing is enabled by default for new CSP licences.

### Governance

Purview controls apply to Cowork: sensitivity labels, audit log, eDiscovery, insider risk management, communication compliance. Administrators set organisation-wide instructions, designate up to 100 reference SharePoint sites and monitor agent usage through a dedicated report.

## User feedback

The published trials agree for both tools: time saved on simple tasks, more reported than measured, and limited trust in answers as soon as the task requires reasoning or figures. Copilot is far better documented, because several government bodies have published their evaluations.

### Published trials and surveys

| Source | Tool | Scope | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| HMRC, UK tax authority, July 2026 | Copilot | 3,500 licences, Sept.–Dec. 2024 | About 60 min saved per week (self-reported, reduced by 20% by HMRC); satisfaction 7.1/10; 46% of non-users cite confidentiality |
| GDS, UK government, June 2025 | Copilot | 20,000 licences, 7,115 responses | 26 min per day reported; usage capped at 23% in Excel and 24% in PowerPoint |
| DBT, UK Department for Business and Trade, August 2025 | Copilot | 1,000 licences, Oct.–Dec. 2024 | 72% satisfied, with no evidence of productivity gain; 22% noted invented answers; Excel slower and less accurate |
| Australian Treasury, February 2025 | Copilot | 218 people, 14 weeks | Useful for basic administrative work, judged unsuitable for complex tasks |
| Gartner, June 2025 | Copilot | 187 IT leaders | 5% of completed pilots move to wide deployment |
| Recon Analytics, February 2026 | Copilot, ChatGPT, Gemini | 150,000 US respondents | When ChatGPT and Copilot are both provided, 76% choose ChatGPT |
| GSA, US federal agency, 2025 | Gemini | 250 staff, 90 days | Used mainly through the web app, little in Workspace; inaccuracy cited as the top risk; time saved not measured |
| State of Utah, January 2025 | Gemini | 257 licences, 4 weeks | 79% of heavy users report 1 to 5 hours saved per week |
| KPMG, November 2025 | Gemini Enterprise | Internal deployment | 90% of employees connected within 2 weeks; data to be cleaned beforehand; risk of agent proliferation |

### Common to both tools

-   **Meetings**: minutes are the most appreciated use, in the trials as on the forums.
-   **Confidently stated errors**: invented rows or data in spreadsheets, incomplete summaries presented as accurate ([ITPro](https://www.itpro.com/technology/artificial-intelligence/google-gemini-ai-for-workspace-is-a-flawed-but-fast-enterprise-ai-heres-what-we-found-with-each-google-app), [Hacker News](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45723030)).
-   **Over-sharing**: any file open to everyone appears in the answers. IT managers recommend auditing permissions and applying sensitivity labels before widening the deployment.
-   **Training**: the public trials all conclude that initial expectations were too high and that training by job role is needed.

### Specific to Copilot

-   Slowness, results that vary from day to day, context forgotten during a conversation (IT service provider forums in late 2025, [Hacker News](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49844896) September 2026). Opinions improve among those who use the reasoning models.
-   Copilot Chat summarised emails labelled confidential despite DLP rules; detected on 21 January 2026, fixed in February ([BleepingComputer](https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/microsoft/microsoft-says-bug-causes-copilot-to-summarize-confidential-emails/)).
-   The Dutch education digital cooperative noted invented information about individuals, then softened its advice from “do not use” to “caution” in September 2025 ([SURF](https://ppc.land/surf-downgrades-microsoft-copilot-education-risks-to-medium-while-privacy-concerns-persist/)).
-   The British and Australian trials cite a benefit for neurodivergent, non-English-speaking or part-time staff.
-   Cowork: first feedback favourable on the output; credit-based billing is cited as the main obstacle (July 2026).

### Specific to Gemini

-   Integration is judged the main strength, but it is enabled by default: switching off the new Gmail features also switches off existing sorting and tabs ([The Register](https://www.theregister.com/2026/01/08/google_gemini_gmail/), January 2026).
-   Text hidden in an email can cause a fake security alert to appear in the summary ([0DIN](https://www.0din.ai/blog/phishing-for-gemini), July 2025).
-   January 2025 price increase: Business Standard goes from $12 to $14, and the $20 Gemini add-on disappears. Cheaper for those who paid for it, more expensive for those who did not use it ([Constellation Research](https://www.constellationr.com/insights/news/google-workspace-drops-gemini-add-charge-raises-business-enterprise-plan-prices)).
-   Quotas since February 2026: 400 Workspace Studio flow runs per month in Business, 2,000 with AI Expanded Access ([UC Today](https://www.uctoday.com/workplace-management/is-your-organisation-actually-using-gemini-or-just-paying-for-it/)).
-   Gemini Enterprise has fewer than ten native connectors, some in preview, and assumes data that is already structured, which is rare in European companies running legacy ERP ([Techzine](https://www.techzine.eu/blogs/applications/140930/mcp-is-just-an-api-and-that-is-precisely-the-problem-with-gemini-enterprise/), May 2026).

Reddit, G2 and Gartner Peer Insights block automated reading: the Reddit threads were read through a mirror, with approximate dates, and no rating from the review platforms is used.

## Undocumented points

-   List of features reserved for the Microsoft 365 Copilot licence compared with free Copilot Chat.
-   Pricing of Copilot Credits and consumption of a typical Cowork task.
-   Availability (general or preview) of the Gemini agent and of colleague agents, and the licence required.
-   Quantified Gemini quotas in Workspace and the price of AI Expanded Access.
-   Official Gemini Enterprise pricing: the figures above come from third-party guides.
-   Availability in French and Spanish: several Gemini features from September 2026 are announced in English only; Microsoft does not specify the language for each new feature.
-   Current status of the Analyst agent, NotebookLM, Gems and Meet: described here from announcements predating 2026, not from the pages consulted.
-   Technical limits (file size, number of documents per request, task duration): not published on the pages consulted.

## Sources

Consulted on 9 November 2026.

### Microsoft

-   [What’s New in Microsoft 365 Copilot, June 2026](https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/blog/microsoft-copilot-blog/what%E2%80%99s-new-in-microsoft-365-copilot--june-2026/4529572), Microsoft Tech Community, 30 June 2026, updated 14 July 2026
-   [Microsoft 365 Copilot release notes](https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/copilot/release-notes), Microsoft Learn, entries up to 4 November 2026
-   [What’s new in Copilot Studio](https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-copilot-studio/whats-new), Microsoft Learn
-   [Microsoft 365 Copilot August 2026 new features](https://admin365.blog/2026/08/14/microsoft-365-copilot-august-2026-new-features/), admin365.blog, 14 August 2026
-   [M365 Copilot pricing reset 2026](https://www.velosio.com/blog/m365-copilot-pricing-reset-2026/), Velosio
-   [Microsoft Copilot Business pricing, SMB buying guide](https://www.infonaligy.com/blog/microsoft-copilot-business-pricing-smb-buying-guide), Infonaligy

### Google

-   [Welcome to Gemini at Work 2026](https://cloud.google.com/blog/products/ai-machine-learning/welcome-to-gemini-at-work-2026), Google Cloud, 8 October 2026
-   [Create content, schedule events and coordinate tasks across Workspace](https://workspaceupdates.googleblog.com/2026/09/create-content-schedule-events-and-coordinate-tasks-across-Workspace-regardless-of-what-app-you-are-in.html), Google Workspace Updates, 9 September 2026
-   [June 2026 Workspace feature drop](https://workspace.google.com/blog/product-announcements/june-2026-workspace-feature-drop), Google Workspace, 26 June 2026
-   [New Gemini capabilities in Google Docs](https://workspaceupdates.googleblog.com/2026/04/new-gemini-capabilities-in-google-docs-help-you-go-from-blank-page-to-brilliance.html), Google Workspace Updates, April 2026
-   [Google rolls out new Gemini capabilities to Docs, Sheets, Slides and Drive](https://www.techcrunch.com/2026/03/10/google-rolls-out-new-gemini-capabilities-to-docs-sheets-slides-and-drive/), TechCrunch, 10 March 2026
-   [Gemini Enterprise pricing](https://dupple.com/learn/gemini-enterprise-pricing), Dupple
-   [Google Gemini Enterprise licensing guide 2026](https://redresscompliance.com/google-gemini-enterprise-licensing-guide-2026.html), Redress Compliance

### User feedback

-   [Evaluating the impact of Microsoft Copilot in HMRC](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/evaluation-report-phase-3-trial-of-microsoft-copilot/evaluating-the-impact-of-microsoft-copilot-in-hmrc), GOV.UK, 9 July 2026
-   [Microsoft 365 Copilot experiment: cross-government findings report](https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/microsoft-365-copilot-experiment-cross-government-findings-report/microsoft-365-copilot-experiment-cross-government-findings-report-html), GOV.UK, 2 June 2025
-   [UK government trial of M365 Copilot](https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/04/m365_copilot_uk_government), The Register, 4 September 2025
-   [Australian Treasury Copilot pilot assessment](https://www.theregister.com/2025/02/12/australian_treasury_copilot_pilot_assessment), The Register, 12 February 2025
-   [AI choice 2026: why licenses don’t equal adoption](https://www.reconanalytics.com/ai-choice-2026-why-licenses-dont-equal-adoption/), Recon Analytics, 4 February 2026
-   [Microsoft says bug causes Copilot to summarize confidential emails](https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/microsoft/microsoft-says-bug-causes-copilot-to-summarize-confidential-emails/), BleepingComputer, 18 February 2026
-   [SURF downgrades Microsoft Copilot education risks](https://ppc.land/surf-downgrades-microsoft-copilot-education-risks-to-medium-while-privacy-concerns-persist/), PPC Land, September 2025
-   [Microsoft 365 Copilot rollouts slowed by data security, ROI concerns](https://www.computerworld.com/article/3542000/microsoft-365-copilot-rollouts-slowed-by-data-security-roi-concerns.html), Computerworld, 27 September 2024
-   [Discussion on the Copilot overhaul](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49844896), Hacker News, September 2026
-   [Evaluating AI users’ needs](https://oes.gsa.gov/projects/2531-evaluating-ai-users-needs/), GSA Office of Evaluation Sciences, 2025
-   [Utah’s journey implementing Gemini across state government](https://innovate-us.org/blog/utahs-journey-implementing-gemini-across-state-government), InnovateUS, 17 January 2025
-   [Google Cloud, KPMG outline lessons learned from Gemini Enterprise deployments](https://www.constellationr.com/insights/news/google-cloud-kpmg-outline-lessons-learned-gemini-enterprise-deployments), Constellation Research, 10 November 2025
-   [Google Workspace drops Gemini add-on charge, raises plan prices](https://www.constellationr.com/insights/news/google-workspace-drops-gemini-add-charge-raises-business-enterprise-plan-prices), Constellation Research, 15 January 2025
-   [Google Gemini AI for Workspace is a flawed but fast enterprise AI](https://www.itpro.com/technology/artificial-intelligence/google-gemini-ai-for-workspace-is-a-flawed-but-fast-enterprise-ai-heres-what-we-found-with-each-google-app), ITPro, 26 May 2025
-   [Discussion on Gemini in Sheets](https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45723030), Hacker News, 27 October 2025
-   [Google Gemini in Gmail](https://www.theregister.com/2026/01/08/google_gemini_gmail/), The Register, 8 January 2026
-   [Phishing for Gemini](https://www.0din.ai/blog/phishing-for-gemini), 0DIN, 10 July 2025
-   [Is your organisation actually using Gemini or just paying for it?](https://www.uctoday.com/workplace-management/is-your-organisation-actually-using-gemini-or-just-paying-for-it/), UC Today, 24 February 2026
-   [MCP is just an API, and that is precisely the problem with Gemini Enterprise](https://www.techzine.eu/blogs/applications/140930/mcp-is-just-an-api-and-that-is-precisely-the-problem-with-gemini-enterprise/), Techzine, 1 May 2026

[← See all insights](https://marsanne.studio/en/insights)
