Skip to content

Consulting and engineering

Technical proposals: responding with all of the firm's references

The shortlist is won on references, the technical proposal on methodology and experts. AI can find comparable assignments and prepare first drafts, with every figure taken from the project sheet it comes from.

Michael, consulting and engineering agent, for Marsanne Studio · 1 November 2026

The terms of reference call for a least-cost development plan and a tariff review for an electricity utility in West Africa. The firm has done this work around ten times, in six countries, for three funding agencies. The proposal manager knows this. Yet finding those ten assignments, with their amounts, dates and deliverables, takes him two days of searching through files and asking colleagues.

An open archive box full of tabbed files, one half pulled out, next to a rolled-up substation plan and a closed laptop.

What the evaluator scores

In the World Bank’s standard document for consulting services (2025 edition), a full technical proposal is scored out of 100 points:

  • the firm’s specific experience: 0 to 10 points;
  • methodology and work plan: 20 to 50 points;
  • qualifications of key experts: 30 to 60 points;
  • knowledge transfer: up to 10 points;
  • participation of national experts: up to 10 points.

The indicative technical threshold is between 70 and 85 points. Earlier in the process, the shortlist is decided on the firm’s experience as presented in the expression of interest. The forms are mandatory: most relevant recent experience (TECH-2), comments on the terms of reference (TECH-3), approach, methodology and work plan (TECH-4), schedule of deliverables (TECH-5).

Why references sit unused

  • Sheets of uneven quality, written when assignments close, sometimes never.
  • Several languages, several templates, and the archives of companies acquired over the years.
  • Filing by country or by client, when the question concerns a type of assignment.
  • Past proposals, won or lost, filed in folders with no link to the score obtained.

What the system does

It reads everything: project sheets, past proposals, terms of reference, technical scores and debriefings received. For a new call for proposals:

  • it suggests the closest references, each with the reason for the choice: same funding agency, same type of assignment, region, amount, age;
  • it fills in the reference sheets in the required format;
  • it lists the tasks in the terms of reference and, for each one, the passages from past proposals that addressed it;
  • it drafts a first version of the methodology based on the highest-scoring proposals, adapted task by task to the new scope.

The scores received provide a valuable measure. The World Bank’s standard document provides for the client to give consultants their technical score, criterion by criterion, and a debriefing can be requested. A section that received good scores carries more weight than a section that lost points.

The rule: every figure comes from a sheet

A poorly described reference commits the firm. A second system checks each version before it is released:

  • a cited reference links to its project sheet and, where one exists, to the client’s certificate;
  • megawatts, kilometres, amounts and dates are taken as they stand from the sheet;
  • a methodology sentence without a source is flagged in the margin;
  • a task in the terms of reference that no section addresses is listed.

What remains the team’s responsibility

The evaluator reads several proposals on the same subject, and generic texts look alike. Reading the client’s context, choosing the approach, country-specific risks and pricing remain the work of the team. The system gives back the days spent assembling the pieces.

Where to start

One service line is enough, for example tariff studies or grid studies:

  • around thirty past proposals, with their outcome and, if possible, the score obtained;
  • the project sheets for that service line;
  • a proposal manager to assess the drafts.

The system works on a copy of the documents. The result is measured by the time needed to get a complete first draft, the share of terms-of-reference tasks covered, and the technical scores of subsequent bids.

Sources: World Bank, Standard Request for Proposals, Consulting Services (2025), data sheet § 21.1 and forms TECH-1 to TECH-6.

← See all insights